Parents in Montgomery County are expressing displeasure with the ‘sexual’ material found in certain books, while the school district maintains that these texts reflect the local family dynamics.
A prince ropes a dragon, rescuing a knight clad in gleaming armor from imminent demise. However, as the prince stumbles, the knight and his horse rush to reciprocate the favor.
Subsequently, the two men develop romantic feelings for each other.
That story,
Prince and Knight
One of these five children’s books highlighting LGBTQ characters, intended for kindergarteners through fifth graders, has stirred controversy within a varied suburban Maryland school district and sparked significant debate.
US
The Supreme Court case that the justices are set to review on Tuesday.
Do you have questions about the biggest topics and trends from around the world? Get the answers with
SCMP Knowledge
Our latest platform features handpicked content including explainers, FAQs, analyses, and infographics, all provided by our esteemed team of experts.
Parents in Montgomery County who have objections based on religious grounds wish to remove their children from elementary school lessons that utilize these books.
The county school system has refused and lower courts have so far agreed.
However, the result might vary when considering a high court heavily influenced by conservative judges who have consistently supported assertions of religious bias in recent times.
The parents contend that public schools have no authority to compel students to engage in teachings that conflict with their religious beliefs. They highlight the existence of opt-out options for sex education and mention that initially, the district permitted parents to remove their children from classes during the reading of these particular storybooks but then suddenly changed this policy.
Although it’s called a language arts program focused on reading and writing, the materials contain highly explicit sexual content,” stated Billy Moges, a member of the Kids First board. “The curriculum covers aspects of human sexuality and seems to be causing confusion among young students. Parents feel uncomfortable with their children being introduced to these topics so prematurely.
Parents group Kids First was formed in response to the addition of the books to the curriculum.
Dozens of parents testified at school board hearings about their religious obligations to keep their impressionable young children from lessons on gender and sexuality that conflicted with their beliefs.
Moges mentioned that she removed her three daughters, who are currently aged 10, eight, and six, from their public schools for this reason. Initially, they were homeschooled before enrolling them in a private Christian school.
The educational institution refrained from commenting, referring to the pending legal case.
‘Everyday tales’
However, according to documents submitted in court, attorneys representing the schools stated that these few storybooks do not serve as sexual education tools but instead “share ordinary stories about characters who embark on adventures, grapple with emerging feelings, and strive to be heard.”
The texts explore similar themes as those present in traditional tales that encompass
Snow White
,
Cinderella
and
Peter Pan
, the lawyers wrote.
In
Uncle Bobby’s Wedding
A niece is concerned that her uncle will have less time for her following his marriage. Her uncle’s spouse is male.
Love, Violet
addresses a girl’s nervousness regarding handing a Valentine to another girl.
Born Ready
This narrative revolves around a transgender boy’s choice to disclose his gender identity both to his family and to society at large.
Intersection Allies
depicts nine characters with diverse origins, including one who identifies as gender-fluid.
The books were selected “to better reflect all Montgomery County families,” and teachers are advised not to use them “to coerce students into changing or renouncing their religious beliefs,” according to statements from the school district’s legal representatives.
The educational institution discontinued the possibility for parents to remove their children from classes due to it becoming “unmanageably disruptive,” according to what the attorneys informed the court.
Writers’ group Pen America, which reported more than 10,000 books banned in the last school year, said in a court filing what the parents want is “a constitutionally suspect book ban by another name”.
The difficulty of providing alternative lessons for some children anytime the books are used probably would force the county to pull the books from the curriculum, Tasslyn Magnusson, senior adviser with the Freedom to Read programme at PEN America, said.
“I genuinely wish people would read these books. They serve as wonderful illustrations of children’s school experiences and make excellent additions to an educational curriculum as decent storybooks,” Magnusson stated.
A book that was initially included in the syllabus but later removed without clear justification is
My Rainbow
, co-authored by Delaware State Representative DeShanna Neal and her daughter Trinity.
The narrative revolves around Trinity’s wish for longer hair as a transgender girl and her mother’s response, which was to knit a colorful rainbow wig for her.
Neal has become accustomed to the book being removed from library shelves in various locations such as Florida, Ohio, and Texas.
School is a place where you understand both the ways and reasons the world varies,” Neal stated. “My hope with this book was for parents to really hear their kids. Children comprehend their own bodies best.
More Articles from SCMP
Get acquainted with Melissa McCarthy’s spouse of two decades, Ben Falcone: this skilled duo initially appeared together in “Gilmore Girls” and since then has teamed up for numerous ventures, including Netflix shows and podcast productions.
The enchantment of Hong Kong’s waterfront regions should not get overshadowed by the pursuit of tourism revenue.
This spring introduces six fresh jewelry releases, and two stand out at the top of our wishlist—Hermès and Cartier. Hermès draws inspiration from their iconic Birkin bag, whereas Cartier opts for an array of designs featuring animals.
The CEO of Nvidia, Jensen Huang, met with the Mayor of Shanghai following new U.S. export restrictions on semiconductor technology.
This article originally appeared on the South China Morning Post (www.scmp.com), the leading news media reporting on China and Asia.
Copyright © 2025. South China Morning Post Publishers Ltd. All rights reserved.